Do Condi and Colin Make the Republicans a Diverse Party? I recently received the following comment:
Well Tom's right that there are at least four non-whites in the Republican Party. I decided to research the percentages of minorities currently serving in elected office. There are 540 members of the Congress (House + Senate combined) but only 74 of them are minorities. This means that whites make up 86.3% of the House even though whites were only 75.1% of the population in the 2000 census. When you account for the fact that the percentage of whites has certainly decreased since the 2000 census, the property right granted by white skin becomes apparent. Minorities are underrepresented in most professions as well. For example, 90% of attorneys are white. The senate.gov website reveals some numbers that prove which party is more diverse. 25 Hispanics are in the 108th Congress. 20 are Democrats, 5 are Republicans. 39 African-Americans serve in Congress. All are Democrats. Let me restate that. There are zero elected black Republican officials in the Federal Government. 7 Asians serve in Congress. 7 are Democrats, 0 are Republicans. 3 Native Americans serve in Congress. The Republicans finally have an advantage (albeit with a ludicrously small sample size) 2-1. Altogether, 68 of the 74 non-whites in Congress are Democrats. 91.8% of the elected minority Congresspeople are Democrats. Tom's claim that the Republicans are the more diverse party is patently false. But Tom is likely not alone in believing that the GOP really is more diverse. I'll tell you why. Just like a bad sitcom, the GOP knows the power of the token black guy. You bring in one or two blacks and suddenly people get the impression that your party isn't full of racists. All of Tom's examples -- Condi, Colin, Alberto Gonzales and Clarence Thomas -- are tokens. All four of these people are aggressively working to harm their race, but that's not the point. You can always find self-hating members of any group and the Republicans welcome those people. That's why you have the occassional gay Republican. The Republicans don't have token minorities on board in order to win minority votes. Non-whites are more keen to the abuses of the Republican party and demonstrate that fact in massive numbers at the ballot box. Blacks voted for Kerry 9-1 in 2004; a majority of Asians and Latinos voted for Kerry as well despite Bush's victory. The reason for these token minorities is to make white people feel safer. Most whites abhor overt racism. People won't vote for a party that is openly racist, so the presence of Condi and Colin make moderate whites feel more comfortable voting Republican. All of this isn't, of course, to say that Condi and Colin aren't perfectly qualified for their positions, despite their political leanings. It's just that the Republicans should have more minorities than the few token ones they do now. Clinton appointed double the minorities that Bush has when you factor in appointments that do not require Senate approval. Most importantly, the number of non-white males working for your administration has nothing to do with what your policies do for non-white males. The pro-corporation, anti-affirmative action, anti-public schools, pro-tax cut, pro-war agenda of the Republican party aggressively favors the interests of those with entrenched privilege, aka white males, over those without, aka everybody else. The Democrats' overwheming advantage in minority representation in Congress, however, speaks volumes as to which party non-whites prefer. The numbers for women are equally troubling and also reveal the Democrats' huge advantage in terms of representation. |
Top Twenty
- 1. Daily Kos
- 2. 538.com (Nate Silver)
- 2. Eschaton (Atrios)
- 3. Huffington Post
- 4. Juan Cole
- 5. The Black Commentator
- 6. This Modern World
- 7. AMERICAblog
- 8. Talking Points Memo -- Joshua Marshall
- 9. TalkLeft
- 10. MyDD
- 11. ed fitzgerald's unfutz
- 12. Eschaton (Atrios)
- 13. Hoffmania
- 14. Pharyngula
- 15. Billmon
- 16. Eric Alterman
- 17. Unclaimed Territory
- 18. Bartcop
- 19. Left in the West
- 20. The Blog From Another Dimension
Recommended News Resources
- Buzzflash!
- The Nation
- The Texas Observer Allafrica.com
- Corporate Crime Reporter Cosmoetica
- Mother Jones Narco News
- Nowpublic Open Democracy
- Today in Iraq Tom Paine
AltWeeklies.com
American Reporter
Am. Politics Journal
Antiwar.com
Arts Journal
Bear Left!
Black Commentator
Bush Watch
Capitol Hill Blue
Common Dreams
ConWebWatch
Consortium News
Corante
CrimeLynx
Cursor
Death Penalty Information Center
Democratic Underground
Dissident Voice
Drudge Retort
Drugwar.com
Eat the State
Econ in Crisis
Failure
The Gadflyer
Grist
History News Network
Hollywood Investigator
Identity Theory
Intervention
The Jackson Progressive
Liberal Oasis
MedialChannel
Memory Hole
Michael Moore
Military Week
The Morning News
New American Media
The New Standard
No Logo
PopMatters
Pop Politics
Press Action
Progressive Review
Raw Story
The Revealer
Salon
Scoop
Slate
Sp!ked
Take Back The Media
The Daily Planet
The Smoking Gun
Truthdig
Truthout
Unknown News
What Really Happened
Wired News
Working for Change
News Services
- Agence France-Presse
- Alternet
- AP
- BBC
- Google News
- Inter Press Service
- Indy Media
- Knight Ridder
- Reuters
- UN
Reference
Government Reference
-
U.S.Constitution
Bill of Rights and Amendments
Contact President Bush
Find Your Representatives
House Web Sites
Senate Web Sites
Blogroll
- Feedster Top 500 Blogs
- The Agonist
- Alas, a Blog
- Amnesty's Death Penalty Blog
- annatopia
- Asian American Empowerment: ModelMinority.com
- Balkinization
- Bartcop
- Billmon
- Blog of the Moderate Left
- The Blogging of the President
- Brains and Eggs
- Brilliant at Breakfast
- Burnt Orange
- The Carpetbagger Report
- David Corn
- Democratic Veteran
- Demagogue
- DMI Blog
- DownWithTyranny
- Easter Lemming Liberal News
- Effect Measure
- Electronic Darwinism
- Emerging Democratic Majority
- Enivornmental and Urban Economics
- ePluribus Media Community
- Eric Alterman
- feministing
- First Draft
- From the Roots
- Gropinator
- Happy Tulip's Xanga Site
- Sister Helen Prejean
- ImpeachBushCoalition
- Informed Dissent
- itlookslikethis
- Just Another Blog
- kid oakland
- Left in the West
- LeftyBlogs.com
- Liberal Street Fighter
mediagirl.org
- Mark Crispin Miller
- Mathew Gross
- The OCD Gen X Liberal
- Orcinus
- Orwell's Grave
- Peking Duck
- Political Cortex
- The Poor Man
- Progressive Blog Digest
- Public Intelligence
- Reaction, The
- Red State Rabble
- Religious Liberal Blog, A
- Republic of T
- The Rude Pundit
- Running Scared
- Sadly, No!
- Say No to Pombo
- ScaramoucheBlog
Skimble
skippy the bush kangaroo
- sustainablog
- Talk Left
- Taylor Marsh/a>
- A Thought Vacuum
- Truth Serum Blog
- Unclaimed Territory
- Upper Left
- Various Miseries
- Washington Note, The
- White Man Ranting
- World Changing
- Zaphod's Heads
- DMI Blog
Organizations Fighting Corporate Evil
- ACLU
- Americans United For Separation of Church and State
- ATLA
- Buy Blue
- CensorBush.org
- Center for American Progress
- Center for Media & Democracy
- ComcastWatch
- Consumers Union
- CorpWatch
- Democrats.org
- Fair.org
- Foundation for Taxpayer & Consumer Rights
- House Democrats' Committee on Government Reform
- Human Rights Watch
- Media Matters for America
- National Organization for Women
- Natural Resources Defense Council
- OpenSecrets
- People For the American Way
- Progressive Democrats of America
- Public Citizen
- Think Progress
- Union of Concerned Scientists
- Union Voice
- WakeUp Walmart
Law Blogs
- ACSBlog
- Arbitrary and Capricious
- Capital Defense Weekly
- CrimProf Blog
- Decision of the Day
- Discourse.net
- Is That Legal?
- The Legal Reader
- Public Defender Dude
- Real Lawyers Have Blogs
- SCOTUSBlog
- Sentencing Law and Policy
For Laughs
Recent Battles in the War on Corporate Evil
- Free Speech and the Internet UPDATEYahoo! has chos...
- Free Speech and the InternetI. Bush = Big BrotherT...
- Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. vs. George W. BushOn M...
- GOP Fights Gore's Straight Talk With LiesLast post...
- The Radical Bloc Emerges: John Roberts Sides With ...
- Al Gore: "It is imperative that respect for the ru...
- Samuel Alito: In His WordsHere's what Alito had to...
- ALITO'S HATRED OF THE RIGHT TO CHOOSE AND THE EQUA...
- Corporate Tool: Samuel AlitoToday the Senate begin...
- When Criminals Become DesperateThe lies of the Bus...
Archives
- August 2005
- September 2005
- October 2005
- November 2005
- December 2005
- January 2006
- February 2006
- March 2006
- April 2006
- May 2006
- August 2008
- September 2008
- November 2008
- January 2012
- June 2013
Corporate Tool Archive
California Resources
San Francisco News
-
Beyond Chron
East Bay Express
Marin Independent Journal Oakland Tribune
SF Bay Guardian
SF Chronicle
SF Examiner
SF Sentinel
SF Weekly
San Jose Mercury News
The Usual Suspects
- SF Indy Media
- SF Bay Area Indy Media Center
- The Bay Area is Talking
San Francisco Resources
American Newspapers
-
Todays Papers
Boston Globe
Chicago Tribune
Detroit Free Press
LA Times
Miami Herald
NY Daily News
NY Newsday
NY Post
NY Sun
NY Times
The Oregonian
Phil Inquirer
Pioneer Press
SP Times
USA Today
Washington Post
Wall Street Journal
International Newspapers
-
NewsLink
Asia Times (HK)
Globe and Mail
Guardian/Observer
The Independent
London Times
Moscow Times
Other Foreign
Pravda (Eng.)
Telegraph U.K.
Times of India
Toronto Star
Magazines
- American Prospect
- Atlantic Monthly
- The Baffler
- Billboard
- Bust
- The Economist
- Found
- Harper's Index
- In These Times
- Left Business Observer
- McSweeney's
- Modern Drunkard
- Mother Jones
- The Nation
- The New Republic
- New Statesman
- New York
- The New Yorker
- Newsweek
- NY Observer
- The Progressive
- Progressive Populist
- Radar
- Reason
- Roll Call
- Time
- US News
- Utne
- Variety
- Wash Monthly
- Weekly Standard
Comments on ""
"Do Condi and Colin Make the Republicans a Diverse Party?"
No. They're rich too.
Your points are well made and true, but money is the real differentiator. Demographically, that still means Whites-Mostly and bigots still welcome, representing a 'token' upgrade from Whites-Only.
You claim the republican party is full of racists. Why do you make that assertion? Because they don't support affirmative action?
And you go further to accuse the "token" minorities in the Bush administration of hating their own race. You don't even consider the possibility that they embrace conservative ideals more than liberal ones. In her own words this is why Condi Rice joined the republican party:
"The first Republican that I knew was my father John Rice. And he is still the Republican that I admire most.
My father joined our party because the Democrats in Jim Crow Alabama of 1952 would not register him to vote. The Republicans did.
I want you to know that my father has never forgotten that day, and neither have I."
The story of why Clarence Thomas is conservative is also interesting but I'll leave for you to research.
Furthermore, there are many blatant examples of racist democrats, i.e. Robert Byrd:
"The Democrats' Klan-coddling today is embodied by KKK alumnus Robert Byrd, West Virginia's logorrheic U.S. senator and, having served since January 3, 1959, that body's dean. Thirteen years earlier, Byrd wrote this to the KKK's Imperial Wizard: "The Klan is needed today as never before and I am anxious to see its rebirth here in West Virginia." Byrd led Senate Democrats as late as December 1988. On March 4, 2001, Byrd told Fox News's Tony Snow: "There are white niggers. I've seen a lot of white niggers in my time; I'm going to use that word." National Democrats never have arranged a primary challenge against or otherwise pressed this one-time cross-burner to get lost."
Still, I won't make the same mistake you did by erroneously characterizing an entire party as racist.
American voters from "minorities" do seem to be generally more intelligent than the rest of us when it comes to casting their ballots.
I like to counter the Robert Byrd argument with names like Strom Thurmond, Jesse Helms, and even George W. Bush. The two Senators may have never been dumb enough to be KKK members like Byrd was, but they haven't done much of anything to advance civil rights. Heck, Dubya even spoke at Bob Jones University, and he was kind of proud of it... I don't think the Republican party is actually "racist", but I do think they don't view race relations or civil rights as an issue of importance.